Welcome to Antonella's Italian Ristorante, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Fayetteville, NC. Situated at 300 Hay St, this restaurant stands out as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine, offering a delightful array of dishes that transport your palate straight to Italy. With an inviting atmosphere and a dedicated staff, Antonella's not only serves food; it curates memorable dining experiences.
When you walk through the doors of Antonella's, you are immediately enveloped in a warm, inviting ambiance that mirrors the charm of an Italian lakeside restaurant. The knowledgeable staff, like Andrew, are eager to cater to your every need, including special dietary requests, ensuring that everyone can indulge in Italy’s culinary delights—like their Portobello Ravioli with Marinara Sauce or Penne Toscana—both celebrated vegan options that do not compromise on flavor.
As you explore the menu, the Italian baguettes catch the eye; the Chicken Parmigiana and Meatball Parmigiana are customer favorites, providing a hearty yet satisfying experience. The emphasis on fresh ingredients is evident in each dish, with flavors that are balanced and expertly crafted. As one diner praised, the fried calamari is both crispy and tender, embodying the essence of great Italian cooking.
In addition to remarkable entrees, Antonella's offers a selection of desserts that will elevate your meal to new heights. The tiramisu has become a signature item, drawing compliments for its authentic taste that feels like home. Each visit is enhanced by thoughtful touches; complimentary bread, butter, and water greet every guest, further embodying the spirit of Italian hospitality.
With glowing reviews from patrons, some even traveling hundreds of miles just to dine here, it’s clear that Antonella’s is worth the visit. The restaurant's commitment to excellent service, led by attentive staff members like Francesca, creates an environment where every meal feels like a celebration. Whether it’s a casual dinner or a special occasion, Antonella's Italian Ristorante is ready to deliver an unforgettable dining experience steeped in tradition and flavor.
So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Antonella's. With a promise of delightful dishes, persuasive flavors, and a cozy atmosphere, it’s no wonder diners leave with full hearts and satisfied appetites.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
3455 Cherokee Rd, Stockton, CA 95205, United States
165 Mallory Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07304, United States
2366 Poplar Dr, Medford, OR 97504, United States
3118 W Northwest Hwy, Dallas, TX 75220, United States
296 E 29th St, Loveland, CO 80538, United States
AJ Bennett
28/10/2025
We had a lovely experience today at Antonelli’s. “Andrew” was very knowledgeable about vegan options. He even made a special dish for us that wasn’t on the menu. Good prices for good food.
Holly K Richardson
03/10/2025
We discovered this place from the staff at the Hampton Inn off 95N three years ago. We now plan our annual leave and round trip to West palm beach from the Catskills to dine at Antonellas’s hoping Francesca is at the bar! Yes we do drive 700 miles to eat here. Go early and grab a seat at the bar — service and food is excellent. Francesca will ensure your visit is memorable. In the heart of Fayetteville downtown— lovely little urban area and street parking is super easy.
Dino Calzolari
26/09/2025
A truly beautiful restaurant, typical of an Italian restaurant found on the lakeside, with truly courteous and professional staff. The fried calamari was very tasty, dry, and crispy. The pasta was also excellent, al dente as tradition demands. The desserts were spectacular; I had a tiramisu, and it felt like home. The espresso was the icing on the cake. If you're in the area, you must try it. A special thanks to Sophia, our waitress.
Livyy Beltran
18/09/2025
I loved this Italian restaurant! Went for my birthday & it was outstanding &beautiful little spot. Food was great! Chicken tasted soo good! Appetizer was the Mozzarella &it was delicious & they give you bread butter &water automatically (: def will be going back
Pascale O
12/09/2025
Best Italian food outside of Italy! Had the sweet and spicy calamari and it was tender and tasty, perfectly balanced. Everything we had was 10/10 awesome. The service was 10/10, Chai was very helpful and friendly. It was our first time and definitely not our last. I'm dying to try the Ossu Buco.
A B
11/08/2025
Mangia bene, ridi spesso, ama molto — and at Antonella’s, you’ll do all three! The service was bellissimo from start to finish, and I even had the chance to chat with the owner — let’s just say she’s as deliziosa to look at as the food is to eat. I went for the lasagna, and mamma mia, it was layered with amore and flavor. Every bite felt like a little Roman holiday on a fork. The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and sprinkled with Italian charm — it’s the kind of place where you feel like family, even on your first visit. If you’re looking for food that’s pasta-tively amazing and an experience that’s amore at first bite, Antonella’s is the place to be. ????????
Donovan Bratsch
19/07/2025
My date and I really like their food. Probably as close to authentic as you can get using available ingredients. Our waitress was super helpful and friendly. We ate inside and there is a nice vibe. There is also nice outside seating. We are looking forward to going back. Update: went back and again both food and service were excellent.
Carreguin
07/07/2025
So many great things to say about the food, service and atmosphere of Antonella’s. While a quite small establishment situated in Dt Fayetteville, it offers an intimate dining experience for any occasion. My wife and I eat here very often. Our favorites include the lasagna dip to start, and a few red sangrias. While we often share our meals, we typically get the salmon or we go straight to desert. The cheesecake was very very good and the cannoli hit the spot. Our server was polite, and gave great recommendations. She even helped with us moving inside due to weather being a bit too hot. I wish I could remember her name so my wife and I could ask for her again. Anyways, I certainly recommend Antonella’s as one of my top 5 restaurants in Fayetteville, NC.